Judge Signals Some Roundup Claims May Survive Supreme Court’s Durnell Ruling
Editors carefully fact-check all Consumer Notice, LLC content for accuracy and quality.
Consumer Notice, LLC has a stringent fact-checking process. It starts with our strict sourcing guidelines.
We only gather information from credible sources. This includes peer-reviewed medical journals, reputable media outlets, government reports, court records and interviews with qualified experts.
Some cancer lawsuits over Roundup herbicide exposure could continue despite a recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling that blocked the main legal argument many plaintiffs used. In a Nov. 14 order, U.S. District Judge Vince Chhabria, who is overseeing hundreds of Roundup lawsuits, said some claims could move forward in certain states if they argue that Roundup’s design makes it too dangerous.
But Chhabria questioned whether the plaintiffs can prove their claims. He wrote that it is not clear that any of them could win. He also said plaintiffs in states that require expert testimony could lose because they had not presented an expert.
Chhabria shared these tentative views ahead of a hearing on Monsanto’s motions for summary judgment. Whitney Di Bona, an attorney and consumer safety advocate at Drugwatch, said the tentative views “give us a rare glimpse into how he’s thinking and the questions he wants answered.”
How the Durnell Ruling Changed the Roundup Cases
In Monsanto v. Durnell, the Supreme Court ruled that a federal pesticide law, the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide and Rodenticide Act (FIFRA), blocks lawsuits alleging that Monsanto failed to warn people, regardless of state labeling regulations. Those lawsuits claimed Monsanto should have had a warning about cancer risks on Roundup’s label. They were the main legal argument in most lawsuits.
After the Supreme Court ruling, some plaintiffs argued that Monsanto should have warned people about risks in its ads and other communications with consumers, even if Roundup’s label didn’t include a warning. But Chhabria said he didn’t see how the law would support that argument. He called it “a made-up tort” that wouldn’t hold up in light of the Durnell ruling.
In October, Bayer, Monsanto’s parent company, won a unanimous jury verdict in a case that tested other legal theories outside the scope of the Durnell ruling.
Chhabria also said lawyers should have expected the Supreme Court’s ruling and raised other legal claims earlier, and suggested he will almost certainly reject the plaintiffs’ requests to change their lawsuits.
Which Roundup Cases Could Continue
Lawsuits claiming that Roundup has a dangerous design may be the most likely to continue. But the lawsuits’ wording matters.
“The biggest question is whether design defect claims can survive,” Di Bona said. “A Missouri state court already let design defect claims go to a jury last month.”
Each state’s laws will likely determine which cases can continue. In states that require an expert to support a design claim, plaintiffs without an expert will likely lose. Chhabria rejected their argument that they should be able to find an expert after their cases return to local courts.
Earlier in November, Bayer CEO Bill Anderson said he expected the court to resolve the remaining lawsuits through a $7.25 billion Roundup settlement that Monsanto’s parent company has offered.